5 Best Fishing Gloves + Buying Guide

By

It only takes one dorsal spine to the hand to become a fishing glove convert. Fishing often occurs in cold, wet, hostile environments and keeping your fingers protected (and warm) is essential to having an enjoyable experience.

I normally like to focus on getting the best fishing rods and reels when getting ready for the next season, but other pieces of equipment can be just as important to have a successful trip.

I became an advocate for fishing gloves after tackling some bigger deep-sea fish that have all kinds of spines, spikes, or scales. When you have spent a few hours in rough weather getting to your secret fishing spot then you don’t want to spend the rest of the week with a sore finger.

Quick Summary – Best Fishing Gloves

Preview
Palmyth Flexible Fishing Gloves Warm for Men and Women Cold Weather Insulated Water Repellent Great...
Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large , Black
Berkley Coated Fishing Gloves, Blue/Grey
Features
Removable fingers for improved dexterity
Non-slip grip
Extremely affordable, treat them as consumable
Waterproof
Not waterproof
Yes - Latex Rubber Coating
Yes - Protective Chemical Coating
Cold Resistant
Not suitable for cold weather
Warm
Not suitable for cold weather
Preview
Palmyth Flexible Fishing Gloves Warm for Men and Women Cold Weather Insulated Water Repellent Great...
Features
Removable fingers for improved dexterity
Waterproof
Not waterproof
Cold Resistant
Not suitable for cold weather
More Info
Product
Preview
Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large , Black
Features
Non-slip grip
Waterproof
Yes - Latex Rubber Coating
Cold Resistant
Warm
More Info
Product
Preview
Berkley Coated Fishing Gloves, Blue/Grey
Features
Extremely affordable, treat them as consumable
Waterproof
Yes - Protective Chemical Coating
Cold Resistant
Not suitable for cold weather
More Info

Fishing Glove Buyer’s Guide

So, how can you tell the difference between a high quality glove that will keep your hands protected for years to come, and a poor quality piece of fabric that will get pierced by the first crab claw that comes your way?

We have put together a simple buyer’s guide to make sure you are considering all of the important details before making your choice.

Durability

The last thing you want is for your gloves to rip and tear after one fishing season. To get the most protection and the most value for money, strong materials should be used.

The main focus here should be on the materials of construction.

There are a few common materials each with different properties, including Neoprene, Polyester, Cotton, and Rubber. Neoprene is especially good for thermal resistance, while rubber is good for rip resistance. The fabric materials like polyester and cotton often serve as a backing for coated material.

Be clear about which scenarios you will using them – for example, you might want different gloves for ice fishing than for filleting fish.

Thermal Properties

If you are interested in ice fishing or even fishing in winter, then the thermal properties of your fishing gloves is key.

The most common fishing gloves for winter or ice fishing are made from neoprene. The thickness here is key, as you will want at least 2 mm to be warm.

Remember – the thicker the gloves the worse their dexterity will be. A particularly good feature is removable fingers that allow for full warmth while covered and full dexterity while removed.

Water Resistance

If you are fishing near the surf with waves breaking around you, or on a boat with icy water splashing onto the deck, then making sure your hands remain dry is an important attribute.

The wrist straps are also crucial here. There are very few gloves that are fully water resistant when submerged.

Style

While most fisherman say that style is not important, the multitude of bright, colorful fishing shirts tells us that is a lie.

This is purely down to personal preference. But don’t pick a pair of gloves based on their design if they do not have sufficient thermal, water, or rip resistant properties for your purposes.

Value

Fishing can be an expensive hobby, so getting the most bang for your buck is crucial. The most important aspect is the durability of your gloves – getting multiple years out of one pair is a great way to bring down the annual cost. So make sure you get the durability correct first.

Another strategy is to select a very affordable pair and buy in bulk then replace them when they have worn out. This allows you to always have a brand new set available.

Best 5 Fishing Gloves

1. Glacier Glove Fishing Gloves

Bestseller No. 1
Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, Large
  • 2mm fleece lined neoprene
  • Seamless palm design
  • 100% waterproof

My Impressions

For anyone who has spent some time winter fishing there is nothing worse than getting cold and wet hands. It can be downright dangerous!

Getting high quality gloves is critical to be able to stay fishing for an extended period of time. Our recommendation is always to select a product that has been designed for ice cold condition. There is a big difference between a warm pair of fishing gloves and a warm pair of winter fishing gloves.

Glacier Gloves have one of the highest ratings on Amazon and have a good reputation for warmth and being waterproof even in extreme conditions.

They do have some issues with splitting and leaking at the seams after hard use, so make sure you inspect yours thoroughly before you begin your next adventure.

Pros

  • Allows for finger dexterity
  • Waterproof
  • Cold Resistant

Cons

  • Weak at the seams
  • Sizing issues

2. Palmyth Flexible Fishing Gloves – Best Fly Fishing Gloves

ON SALE $12.83 OFFBestseller No. 1
Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold...
  • Convertible Mitt: Easily converts from warm mittens to fingerless gloves with magnets; Thus freeing...
  • 3M Thinsulate: The gloves are insulated with 40 grams 3M thinsulate, orange microfiber fleece and...
  • Silicone Palm Grips: Partial synthetic leather and premium Anti-Slip silicone enhance grip and...

My Impressions

A personal problem I have with most gloves is when you have to take them off to tie a new fly lure onto your fishing line. That 2 minute window can really freeze your hands in very cold conditions.

The beauty of these Palmyth flexible gloves is the removable fingers. This allows you full dexterity while still keeping your palms covered up.

Pros

  • Removable fingers for improved dexterity  
  • Adjustable wrist straps for comfort
  • Warm fleece lining

Cons

  • Not very waterproof
  • Not suitable for cold weather

3. Berkley Coated Fishing Gloves – Best Waterproof Fishing Gloves

ON SALE $1.81 OFFBestseller No. 1
Berkley Coated Fishing Gloves, Blue/Grey
  • Coated gloves with textured grip
  • Heavy duty yet flexible
  • Protect hands from fish handling hazards

My Impressions

One of the most popular gloves for fishing is the Berkley. With over 1200 reviews they are extremely common, and I’m sure you have seen someone wearing them at a pier or boat.

They are also extremely affordable at less than $10. You cannot go wrong with this brilliant entry level gloves. And at this price you can easily buy in bulk and throw them away when they prove to lose their performance.

Pros

  • Protective coating  
  • Very affordable
  • Over 1200 positive reviews

Cons

  • Review the sizing guide thoroughly – can be small for their size
  • Not particularly durable

4. Rapala Marine Fishing Gloves – Best Bass Fishing Gloves

ON SALE $2.20 OFFBestseller No. 1
Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large , Black
  • Non-slip fish handling gloves.
  • Fresh or Saltwater
  • designed to float

My Impressions

If there is one brand that gives fisherman hope it is Rapala. Renowned for making excellent fishing equipment, these Marine fishing gloves are no exception.

These gloves are designed for handling live fish and have a latex rubber coating to provide a non-slip grip.

They are also machine washable to get rid of that fishy smell.

These are not designed for filleting fish and are not knife resistant so be careful with gutting your catch.

Pros

  • Excellent protection
  • Warm and flexible

Cons

  • Not knife resistant
  • Sizing fit issues – check the sizing tables

5. Stormr Strykr 2mm Neoprene Gloves – Best Winter Fishing Gloves

ON SALE $8.01 OFFBestseller No. 1
OZERO Touch Screen Gloves for Men, Winter Warm Touch Glove for Smart Phone Texting with Non-Slip...
  • STYLISH FOR MEN - OZERO windproof and water resistant touchscreen sensitive gloves are fashion and...
  • SENSITIVETOUCHSCREEN FINGERTIP PADS - Keep your fingers warm and dry while you use your devices....
  • WATER RESISTANT AND WINDPROOF FABRIC AND TPU - High-quality water resistant shell keeps your hands...

My Impressions

When it comes to winter fishing, it is hard to look past the Stormr 2mm neoprene fishing gloves. The neoprene means that they are extremely warm. They are rip resistant and waterproof (unless submerged), so will protect your fingers from the elements.

They have adjustable wrist straps to get a tight fit and be comfortable. The only downside is a lack of dexterity when trying to do something delicate – but this is a trade off between warmth.

Pros

  • Rip resistant
  • Water-tight seems
  • Warm – 2mm neoprene

Cons

  • Not waterproof when submerged

3 Reason to Wear Fishing Gloves

Still not convinced? Watch this video by Lojo for a few new reasons to wear fishing gloves.

​Frequently Asked Questions

Why do you need fishing gloves?

It only takes one dorsal spine to the hand to realize why most anglers wear gloves. Fish are often slippery with sharp scales, so having a layer of rubber between the fish and your hands is crucial.
Fishing is also often cold and wet so having insulated gloves can make the whole experience more comfortable, even when ice fishing.

What are fishing gloves made from?

Fishing gloves can be made from anything including rubber, latex, mesh, fabric, neoprene, and leather. The ideal material depends on your environment and weather conditions. Ice fishing is better with neoprene , while less cold conditions can be better with fabric or rubber.

Conclusion

That brings us to the conclusion of this article. If you haven’t ever worn gloves fishing then you should give it a try. You might be surprised at how much heat is lost through your hands, particularly in colder areas.

If you have any feedback or recommendations of the best fishing gloves of your own, then please leave a comment below.

Happy fishing!

Last update on 2022-01-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Photo of author

Russ Egan

Russ is an avid fisherman. He has fished all over the world for more than two decades, primarily for saltwater game fish but also for local trophy fish. Russ writes reviews for all of his fishing gear to help others achieve their own fishing goals. His favorite reel is a Shimano Curado Baitcaster. His dream is to catch a Black Marlin.