10 Best Conventional Reels for Saltwater Trolling Big Gamefish

When you are targeting gamefish like tuna or marlin you will want to have to best conventional reel available. The last thing you want is to have gear failure and watch the fish swim into the distance.

I have put together this list of the top 10 conventional reels for game fishing as well as a buyer’s guide and an explanation of some key criteria you will want to think about before making a purchase decision.

Conventional fishing reels offer a proven design for retrieving long lengths of heavy line. They also have lower gear ratios to pull in larger fish.

It doesn’t matter if you call them Conventional Reels, Offshore Reels, Trolling Reels, or Overhead Reels.

Conventional fishing reels are also ideal for bottom fishing. If you are looking to go offshore fishing for large reef fish then have a look at these saltwater conventional fishing reels.

Quick Summary – Best Conventional Reels

• Best Overall: Shimano Tiagra
• Best Value for Money: Shimano Tyrnos
• Best Budget Option: PISCIFUN Salis X

Why Use a Conventional Reel for Big Gamefish?

Conventional reels have two advantages over spinning reels when it comes to catching larger fish:

• Lower gear ratios
• Higher line capacity

Conventional reels have lower gear ratios which means they will retrieve less line per crank but they have more torque which is particularly valuable when fighting against fish that can be heavier than you are.

They also have more line capacity. Remember, you will need more length of a higher diameter line so the size of the spool needs to be exponentially larger for big fish.

Conventional Reel Buyer’s Guide

Chasing big gamefish like tuna, marlin, or sailfish is a very different sport then popping down to your local lake to catch a bass. You need much larger gear from your line, hooks, and rod and reel.

The preference of experienced anglers for game fishing reels is to use an overhead conventional reel. 

But there are many different sizes and designs of conventional reels that will change your fishing experience. I have put together this buyer’s guide to showcase the requirements you should be looking for to help make a good purchase decision.

Max Drag Requirements

Appling drag to your reel should not be an art but a science. Drag is used to apply a constant force on the fleeing fish and to prevent your line from snapping.

Because of this you can use the strength of your line to know exactly how much drag you should be applying.

But it does depend on what type of line you are using – mono and braid fishing lines have different properties.

How much drag do you need for mono line?

Mono line has a fair bit of stretch in it which means you can set your drag higher than you would for braid as the line is less likely to break under the same instantaneous force applied.

• Up to 20 lb Mono Line – 20% of the line breaking strength
• 20 to 50 lb Mono Line – 25% of line breaking strength
• 50 lb and up Mono Line – 30% of line breaking strength

How much drag do you need for braid line?

Braid line doesn’t have any of the stretch of nylon monofilament fishing line. This means you will need to be more conservative with setting your drag. Please see our recommendations for setting your drag below:

• Up to 20 lb Braid Line – 15% of line breaking strength
• 20 to 65 lb braid line – 20% of line breaking strength
• 65 lb and up braid line – 25% of line breaking strength

Remember – when going after big gamefish you want to be precise. Don’t set your drag using gut feel. Get out the scales to set it correctly.

Line Capacity Requirements

When a large black marlin takes your lure and flees into the distance at full speed you can easily lose hundreds of meters of line in under a minute.

Most game fishermen recommend having at least 500 yards of line when going after gamefish like Marlin or Sailfish.

Remember, the thicker diameter line you have the less length you can fit. So make sure you consider both aspects when looking at the spool size and line capacity.

10 Best Conventional Reels

Let’s dive into the best 10 conventional reels available on the market at the moment.

1. Shimano Tyrnos

Overall Score – 5/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Shimano Tyrnos is my personal conventional reel. I have used it to catch plenty of tuna and mackerel – no marlin yet, but not due to lack of trying.

I am a big Shimano fan and this conventional reel is no exception.

One of the features of the Tyrnos is the two speed lever. This means you can have two different gear ratios depending on whether you need a fast retrieve (if you are bring a lure back to the boat) or a slow retrieve (when that previously mentioned marlin has taken a bite).

What I Like About It

It is a good medium positioned reel that has higher quality materials than the TLD but is less expensive than the Tiagra. It is a great value for money alternative that can also be used for bottom fishing.

Gear Ratio – 5.0:1

Max Drag – 33 pounds of drag

Mono Line Capacity – 550 yards of 30 pound mono

Braid Line Capacity – 900 yards of 50 pound braid

Pros

• Great value for money
• Suitable for gamefish trolling and bottom fishing
• Two speed gearing system

Cons

• More expensive than Shimano’s TLD alternative

2. PISCIFUN Salis X

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

For something a bit different have a look at the Salis X. It is a much smaller reel than some of the other options and is substantially cheaper.

With a higher gear ratio of 6.2 it has a much higher retrieve rate per crank. This means it is suitable for smaller fish as well. But you will have to fish smarter when chasing the monster species.

What I Like About It

With over 500 yards of line capacity for a heavy 80 lb braid this is certainly a viable option to consider.

It has a rigid graphite frame and oversized pinion and main gears to give a smooth retrieve motion. 

This reel is one from left field but has earned my recommendation as the best budget level conventional reel.

Gear Ratio – 6.2:1

Max Drag – 37 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 490 yards of 30 lbs

Braid Line Capacity – 520 yards of 80 lbs

Pros

• Substantially cheaper than Shimano’s alternatives
• Ideal for smaller saltwater fish

Cons

• Has a high gear ratio that might not give enough drag for saltwater gamefish

3. Daiwa Saltiga

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Daiwa Saltiga is a well known reel with a lot of passionate fans. 

It is also very well made with a focus on corrosion resistance. The CRBB (Corrosion Resistant Ball Bearings) stainless steel ball bearings last 12 times longer than standard stainless steel ball bearings. And the bronze pinion gears give a smooth retrieve motion with high power.

What I Like About It

The Saltiga is a medium sized reel with a good 40 lb max drag but a higher 6.3:1 gear ratio so it is suitable for smaller fish that need to be retrieved quickly. But the two speed options give a much lower 2.3 gear ratio and should be your choice when going after the big fish.

With over 15 different models including single speed and two speed as well as 2 tournament style sailfish specialists – you will find one that suits your needs.

Gear Ratio – 6.3:1

Max Drag – 40 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 420 yards of 40 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 660 yards of 80 lb

Pros

• Two speed gearing systems are options
• Good combination of value for money, powerful drag, and line capacity
• High quality, durable ball bearings

Cons

• Medium sized conventional reel that might not cut it against large saltwater gamefish

4. Okuma Classic CLX

Overall Score – 3/5 ⭐⭐⭐

The Okuma Classic CLX is another option to consider. With a graphite frame, aluminum handle, stainless steel foot, and stainless steel guide system this is well made.

What I Like About It

Personally I prefer a level drag rather than a star drag like the CLX. The star drag is more adjustable but it just means there is something else you need to be fiddling with instead of focusing on the battle. This is only useful if you have set the drag wrong to begin with.

At under 20 ounces this is a smaller and lighter reel. It has an unusual combination of a low gear ratio and a lower max drag.

This is substantially cheaper than the Shimano options but at this price point I think I would prefer the PISCIFUN.

Gear Ratio – 3.8:1

Max Drag – 13 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 310 yds of 25 lb

Pros

• Substantially cheaper than the larger options
• Lightweight

Cons

• Star drag can be difficult to adjust during a fight
• Very low max drag

5. Penn International

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Penn International is a close second to the Shimano Tiagra. It is a big, big reel. The low 3.1:1 gear ratio means it will generate huge torque even against the largest fish.

What I Like About It

It has a high max drag and an enormous line capacity of over a mile depending on the line you select.

If I walked onto a marlin charter and saw Penn International reels in the rod holders then I would be very happy.

Gear Ratio – 3.1:1

Max Drag – 65 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 1120 yards of 80 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 3025 yards of 130 lb

Pros

• Very powerful drag and low gear ratio can handle any gamefish on the planet
• Ridiculously high line capacity

Cons

• Extremely large and heavy reel

6. Shimano Tiagra

Overall Score – 5/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

If you are going after trophy black marlin then I wouldn’t want anything other than the Shimano Tiagra. It is an absolutely monstrous reel with a 2.2:1 gear ratio and 100 lbs of drag. This is the kind of reel you want on your side when going after fish weighing hundreds of pounds.

What I Like About It

Depending on what diameter fishing line you select this reel will hold more than a mile of line! Even when the largest gamefish starts spooling off your line you will be comfortable.

The downside – when you are fishing for anything other than gamefish then this reel is overkill. It isn’t particularly versatile and you wouldn’t want to go after some smaller tuna or mackerel.

This is certainly the premier conventional reel for big gamefish.

Gear Ratio – 2.2:1

Max Drag – 100 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 1000 yards of 130 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 3315 yards of 150 lb

Pros

• This is the best conventional reel available on the market, in my opinion
• 100 lb of max drag
• Over 1000 yard line capacity can handle anything

Cons

• Extremely expensive and heavy duty
• This is overkill for anything less than the largest gamefish

7. Okuma Cortez

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Okuma has its own Mechanical Stabilizing System which ties together the spool shaft, pinion gear, pinion gear bearing, drive shaft and main gear so they stay in alignment.

It has an aluminum anodized spool, aluminum frame, graphite side plates, and an ergonomic handle for comfort (even when your hands are wet).

What I Like About It

The Okuma Cortez also boasts a magnetic control system which boasts to achieve further casting distance – casting is not a normal part of game fishing.

The combination of a high gear ratio, low max drag, and lower line capacity means that it doesn’t make the top of my list.

Gear Ratio – 6.2:1

Max Drag – 17 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 410 yards of 14 lb

Pros

• Suitable for smaller saltwater fish
• Able to cast longer distances than the alternates

Cons

• A relatively low max drag for a saltwater reel

8. Shimano TLD

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Shimano TLD is the entry level conventional reel compared with the Tyrnos and Tiagra. It has a low gear ratio that will help it fight big fish but only a 22 lb max drag.

This doesn’t mean that you can’t catch big fish. It just means that you will have to fish smarter and let the fish take a lot of line before you can man-handle it back to the boat. You may also have to chase the fish with your boat if it is truly large.

What I Like About It

It can still hold 900 lbs of fairly heavy braid line so it is a viable option for sailfish. The materials of construction are not as high quality as the Shimano alternatives but the price is substantially lower.

Gear Ratio – 3.6:1

Max Drag – 22 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 600 yards of 30 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 980 yards of 65 lb

Pros

• Very large spool line capacity
• Very affordable option full of Shimano’s technologies

Cons

• Lower max drag than I would like

9. Penn Squall

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Penn Squall has a good combination of lightweight design, corrosion resistance, and adjustability. The two speed gearing system allows you to change the gear ratio and retrieve rate per turn depending on what you are doing and what size fish you hook.

What I Like About It

The lever drag allows you to snap the drag settings into the correct position very easily at a moments notice.

The black and gold design is also very stylish and will be a good addition to any anglers reel collection.

Gear Ratio – 2.9:1

Max Drag – 40 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 890 yards of 50 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 2145 yards of 80 lb

Pros

• Very good combination of power, weight, and price point
• Lever drag lets you set the required drag instantly

Cons

• Low gear ratio results in a lower retrieve rate

10. Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3

Overall Score – 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 is a much more versatile reel. It has a higher gear ratio and low max drag than the big reels. To be honest it is a much smaller reel. You wouldn’t want to chase massive marlin with this reel but it would be perfect for smaller tuna and mackerel.

What I Like About It

The C3 is a well liked reel amongst anglers and if you intend to do a bit of gamefishing and a bit of another kind of fishing with the same reel then I would consider this.

It is a good combination of brute strength and refined style.

Gear Ratio – 5.3:1

Max Drag – 15 lbs

Mono Line Capacity – 320 yards of 12 lb

Braid Line Capacity – 310 yards of 30 lb

Pros

• Extremely versatile reel

Cons

• Very low max drag

Conclusion

That brings us to the end. I hope you have gained something from reading this article and have found a few different models that you will consider for your next saltwater fishing adventure.

When making your selection I will give one piece of advice – when going after big gamefish then always, always, always pick quality. Once you have spent thousands of dollars on gear, travel, boating, and other gear you may only get one or two bites from your target species. The one thing you don’t want is your gear to let you down.

Whether this is your rod, reel, fishing lines, fishing hooks, or even a simple swivel – always pick quality when it counts.

There are plenty of other options you might be interested in that didn’t make our list such as the Shimano Calcutta, Tekota, Torium, or Triton.

If you have experience in using any of the conventional fishing reels listed in this article then please share your thoughts in the comments below. I love to hear from our readers and to gain from your wisdom.

Another piece of advice – if you are chasing big gamefish then make sure you get a high quality fighting belt to save your body from the strain of a multiple hour fight. You should also consider getting an electric conventional reel if you are fishing deep.

Happy fishing!

Last update on 2022-01-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API